Ryanair Holdings plc

Moat: 2/5

Understandability: 2/5

Balance Sheet Health: 4/5

Ryanair is a low-cost airline group, connecting various airports across Europe and North Africa through point-to-point routes, known for its low fares.

Investor Relations Previous Earnings Calls

The moat, understandability, and balance sheet health scores reflect a conservative evaluation to ensure a margin of safety in any assessment.

Ryanair operates in the highly competitive airline industry, where its “moat,” or competitive advantage, is derived from a complex combination of cost efficiency, scale, and strategic route selection. While the company has been highly successful in maintaining its position as a low-cost carrier, it faces multiple threats, including external factors that could impact its profitability.

Moat Assessment: 2/5

Ryanair has a business model that is difficult to replicate, but it does not have a true wide moat. It is more appropriate to classify the moat as narrow, but with the possibility of erosion.

  • Cost Efficiency: Ryanair has one of the lowest cost structures in the airline industry, which can be attributed to several factors, including flying a single type of aircraft (Boeing 737), a high utilization rate for its fleet, low airport fees, and a focus on point-to-point routes, which limits hub complexities. However, these are operational and managerial strengths and therefore aren’t structural as much as intangible and can be copied. This gives them cost advantage over competitors but it is not structural or defensible.

  • Scale: Ryanair’s vast network of routes, particularly its dominance in several European markets, provides an advantage in terms of brand recognition and network effects. The size of the operation and the number of destinations can give it leverage over competitors in negotiations and reduce cost. Although network and scale are helpful, there is no monopoly or oligopoly, which leaves it vulnerable to competitive attacks.

  • Switching Costs (Low): Unlike some industries where customers might experience significant friction from switching between providers (e.g., cloud computing or enterprise software), airline customers face almost no such cost. They can compare multiple airlines prices and routes online and make a booking within minutes. There is no loyalty or cost involved in switching, so customers could leave very easily. There are some aspects of the customer experience in which Ryanair is leading, but that’s not a switching cost as much as a differentiator that can attract and retain customers, and competitors can easily catch up with those.

  • Brand Reputation (Questionable): While Ryanair is a well-known brand, it does not usually evoke brand loyalty the way that consumer packaged goods brands, such as Coca-Cola, do. Many consumers choose their carrier based entirely on price and availability. However, its brand does have value for recognition, especially on the web and through advertisements.

  • Intangible Assets (Limited): Ryanair holds no patents or regulations (except for its operating licences), and is mainly a company that uses its scale and processes to produce a cheap product rather than innovation, so it has limited value from intangible assets.

Legitimate Risks to the Moat

  • High Fuel Costs: Jet fuel prices are notoriously volatile and are among the major costs for airlines. Since the Company’s operating costs are very low, any big fluctuation in fuel prices would directly translate into reduced earnings and profitability. This also means that if the company has to raise fares to adjust for this cost, it loses its low cost advantage and faces competition from other airlines.

    • Management Comments: The company attempts to hedge these costs at approximately 85% of expected needs for the next 12 months, and some even up to 24 months.
  • Regulatory Changes and Government Intervention: Changes in regulations related to airports, competition, and safety can increase operating costs and can also disrupt markets. Governments may decide to reduce fees or change routes. For instance, recently Ryanair’s operations were severely affected by a government decision regarding airports in Portugal.
  • Labor Costs and Strikes: Ryanair is known for having less costly labor than competitors, this comes at the cost of bad employee and union relationships. Ryanair has had strikes in the past and these kinds of issues can be difficult to navigate and resolve. Also, any increase in employee compensation would greatly affect the low cost strategy and the profitability.
  • Intense Competition: The low-cost airline sector is intensely competitive, and new players with new business models emerge frequently. Any new innovative business model could damage Ryanair if it is implemented correctly. Also, major airlines, like Air France and Lufthansa are attempting to operate lower cost airlines in order to compete with Ryanair. Ryanair needs to be very efficient in operating its business in order to maintain its profitability over competitors.
  • Economic Slowdowns: Any recession or similar downturn would likely cause consumers to travel less, and for less fare, further impacting profitability. Also, in a weaker economy, competitors will reduce prices to stay relevant, damaging airlines that rely on low-cost operations.

Business Description

Ryanair operates a low-cost business model characterized by high aircraft utilization, low labor and fuel costs, and an emphasis on point-to-point travel.

  • Revenues: The main sources of revenue are from ticket sales, and additional revenue comes from ancillaries such as luggage fees, food and drinks, travel insurance, car rentals, and hotel bookings.
  • Route Distribution: Ryanair operates a network of short-haul point-to-point routes throughout Europe and North Africa. It focuses on routes that connect smaller airports, often to avoid high airport fees.
  • Trends: The industry has seen a consistent growth in low-cost flights, with point-to-point travel gaining in popularity, but it is important to mention that the European market is mature with limited opportunities for growth and new routes in many areas. There has also been a large growth in ancillary revenue, which could be considered as both a strength and weakness for airlines. The industry is also undergoing increased environmental pressure due to climate change concerns, with legislation that will likely have a large impact in the near term future.
  • Margins: The operating margins are traditionally very high for Ryanair because of its low-cost structure and efficiencies. Although fuel prices could affect this, generally low costs and the high volume of passengers help maintain operating margins.
  • Competitive Landscape: The European airline market is crowded with established players like Air France and Lufthansa, and low-cost carriers like EasyJet, Wizz Air, and Eurowings. This leads to intense competition and pressure on prices. Ryanair must keep costs to a minimum if it wishes to compete efficiently.
  • What Makes Ryanair Different:
    • Ryanair does not operate many routes with connecting passengers, so it has limited losses from missed connections and similar.
    • The company is known for aggressively negotiating for low airport fees and incentives.
    • Ryanair is constantly focused on streamlining operations and reducing costs. For example, the new Boeing 737 MAX aircraft it has ordered has better fuel efficiency and more seating capacity, therefore reducing its costs significantly.

Financial Analysis

  • Revenues: Revenue increased by 38% compared to the previous year, due to a much more active year with fewer COVID restrictions. Revenue rose from 4.8 Billion euros to 6.6 Billion euros. However, this is still well below its pre-covid levels.
  • Net Income: The company swung into a positive net income of 142 million euros, after the previous two years in the red. Although this is positive it is still less than before the pandemic, and only anemic.
  • Cash Flow: Cash flow is very volatile because of the seasonality of travel and the large fluctuations in fuel prices. The company had a positive cash flow for this year.
  • Liquidity & Solvency: Ryanair has a large amount of cash assets that helps it operate smoothly through the seasons. The company has been aggressive in paying back its large debt position, and also has relatively low debt.

Despite the positive results of 2023, the company faces some immediate issues as it is having large delivery delays with Boeing due to supply chain issues. Ryanair management is trying its best to get around this and secure new deliveries from Boeing but these delays may have a large impact on its profitability in the immediate future.

Understandability: 2/5

The company’s core operations as an airline are relatively easy to understand, however the financial complexity of the company, as well as the intricacies of its hedging strategies, can make things difficult for the average investor. Also, the company’s legal troubles related to its operations makes it a business that requires research to have a good understanding of.

Balance Sheet Health: 4/5

Ryanair’s balance sheet can be considered as above average health. Although the company has taken on high debt levels in the past, it has managed to improve its debt structure and liquidity in recent years. The main point of concern remains if they’ll be able to maintain their low debt and cash positions, as this has been something that has plagued them in the past.

In summary, RYAAY has some competitive advantages and strengths in the low-cost airline industry but has some weaknesses as well as major threats that it needs to manage appropriately, and therefore it has a medium narrow moat. The business is relatively easy to understand, although it has some financial complexity, and has good balance sheet health. Investors should be wary of recent turbulence surrounding the supply chain, especially from its aircraft provider Boeing.