W. R. Berkley Corporation

Moat: 3/5

Understandability: 2/5

Balance Sheet Health: 4/5

W. R. Berkley Corporation is an insurance holding company that writes commercial insurance through its multiple operating units. The company’s operations span throughout the United States and overseas, providing a range of property and casualty insurance solutions.

Investor Relations Previous Earnings Calls

The moat, understandability, and balance sheet health scores reflect a conservative evaluation to ensure a margin of safety in any assessment.

W. R. Berkley Corporation, operating since 1967, is a well-established property and casualty insurance provider with a diverse portfolio, however, as a result of these operations, there is much complexity in its financials.

Business Overview

W. R. Berkley Corporation operates primarily in the commercial insurance sector. This includes a wide array of specialized insurance products and services, written through a decentralized network of operating units that maintain autonomy in their management. This allows the company to cater to various niches, and also limits management concentration risk. Their revenue is distributed across a wide array of insurance lines, making them less vulnerable to specific risks.

  • Lines of Business: Their offerings range from standard commercial insurance, such as workers’ compensation and general liability, to more specialized lines like professional liability, cybersecurity insurance, and reinsurance.
  • Global Presence: While it has a large base in the US, it is worth mentioning that it also serves a diverse international market, including Asia, Canada, Europe, and South America, that further provides protection against any single economy or region slowdown.
  • Decentralized Structure: W. R. Berkley operates a decentralized, autonomous operating model, where its individual business segments function with a high degree of independence. This enables faster decision-making by experts who are close to the market. The idea is that local managers know best, and helps the business better understand and react to their particular area requirements.
  • Client Focus: The company focuses on building long-term relationships by offering highly specialized and customized products, designed to meet the unique needs of their clients.
  • Specialty focus: The company emphasizes underwriting profitability by selecting specialty risks where competition is not as fierce and the company has an expertise.

Competitive Landscape

The insurance industry is very competitive, with major players such as Travelers, AIG, Chubb, Allstate, Liberty Mutual, and Berkshire Hathaway’s insurance division, competing with a myriad of local, specialty, and regional insurance firms. W. R. Berkley stands out by maintaining a decentralized model that gives its operating units significant freedom in their processes, but that does not constitute a very defensible moat as competitors also can adopt it. The “moat” arises from the scale and risk analysis advantages the company possesses that others might not have, and also their focus on specialized areas and custom solutions. Their management has extensive experience and history of being able to underwrite profitably.

Financial Analysis

W.R. Berkley’s most recent financial results are from their Form 10-Q for the period ended March 31, 2023, and the year-ended December 31, 2022, respectively. Income Statement Overview

  • Revenues: The company’s consolidated revenues was $2,973.4 million for the three months ended March 31, 2023 and increased by $305.2 million or 11.5% to $2,973.4 million from $2,668.2 million for the three months ended March 31, 2022. For the year ended December 31, 2022 total revenues were $11,742.6 million compared to $10,091.4 million in 2021, a 16.3% increase. Premiums earned are the bulk of the revenue stream, with net investment income being a small portion (net investment income was $213.5 million for the first three months of 2023, compared to premiums of $2,470.3 million).

W.R. Berkley’s ability to consistently grow premiums and net investment income highlights its core revenue drivers and a significant competitive advantage.

  • Profitability: For the first three months of 2023, the company reported net income attributable to the Company of $501.1 million, or $2.26 per share, compared with $301.3 million, or $1.33 per share, for the three months ended March 31, 2022. For the year ended December 31, 2022 they reported net income attributable to the company of $960.7 million compared to $714.7 million in 2021, a 34.4% increase. This shows a good ability of the company to translate revenues into profits.
  • Operating Efficiency: A key measure in the insurance industry is the combined ratio (the sum of a company’s loss ratio and expense ratio) and is the insurance company’s profitability metric. As a rule, a number below 100% indicates that the insurer is profitable in their underwriting operations. For the most recent quarter, W. R. Berkley’s combined ratio improved significantly to 89.9 percent from 93.6 percent for the same period a year ago, suggesting improved underwriting profitability. For the year ended December 31, 2022, the combined ratio was at 91.7%, compared to 93.6% in the year prior, indicating improvement in profitability in both the longer term and recent periods.
  • Loss Ratio: The Loss ratio shows the percentage of revenue that the insurer has to pay out for insured losses, it’s a critical ratio for insurance companies and is heavily impacted by factors that are specific to a particular period (economic situation, natural events) but an upward or downward trend can indicate whether the company is getting better or worse at evaluating the risks they take on and pricing accordingly. W.R. Berkley showed a loss ratio of 59.2% for the first three months of 2023, compared to a loss ratio of 62.6% for the same period last year.

The increase in profits and improved combined ratios indicate strong underwriting efficiency, which is a good sign of the company’s moat.

Balance Sheet Analysis

  • Assets: W. R. Berkley’s balance sheet shows a solid financial position. They have a large asset base that mainly consists of fixed maturities and equity investments as well as cash and cash equivalents. As of March 31, 2023, the company has total assets of $36.3 billion
  • Debt and Equity: On the other side, they had $8.8 billion in debt and 23.4 billion in equity, a leverage level that is not too high compared to the industry average and is well manageable.
  • Liquidity and Financial Flexibility: The company has an adequate liquid assets and access to debt markets, allowing them to maintain operational flexibility and also pursue investment and growth opportunities as they see fit.

Moat Assessment

W.R. Berkley’s moat can be characterized as having several sources of competitive advantage, though they aren’t very durable or strong. They include:

  • Experienced and decentralized management: Allowing operating segments to perform autonomously increases the risk management efficiency, and allows for faster decision making and a better understanding of risks. This is not a defensible advantage on its own, as other companies can do it, but they are still more resilient due to it.
  • Diverse Insurance Portfolio: Being diversified across different insurance lines, markets, and geographies limits the impact of any one single adverse event, limiting overall operational risk.
  • Pricing Expertise: Insurance pricing is quite complex and requires strong analytical capabilities to understand risk. Their focus on specialty insurance areas, where pricing is more bespoke and reliant on actuarial skills and risk management, limits the potential for competition.
  • Scale advantages: Due to being a large company with many operations, the company can benefit from economies of scale. This can also include having data and analytics advantages in determining risks and pricing, but not a guaranteed advantage as others can invest in these.

Based on this analysis, the rating of W.R. Berkley’s moat is: 3 / 5 . Their economic advantages, although notable are not enough to give them a higher rating.

Risks Affecting the Moat

  • Competitive Pressures: Insurance is a very competitive industry with many players, all competing to attract customers by lowering prices. This could erode Berkshire’s competitive advantage if the company is unable to effectively compete on price. Additionally, insurers are often forced to match prices on certain coverage by competitors. In particular, some of their competitors are larger or have more capital, and can also try to erode the small company’s market share by offering lower rates.
  • Interest Rate Volatility: The company earns a small portion of its revenue from investments. Low interest rates reduce their income, and high inflation leads to reduced purchasing power. The company could struggle if interest rates are too low and don’t give sufficient returns, or too high and they can’t price their liabilities accordingly. They are reliant on good economic conditions in that sense. Also, as explained in the previous section, changes in rates can dramatically influence the company’s capital structure.
  • Regulatory Changes: The insurance industry is heavily regulated, and any changes in regulation could negatively affect the company. Some states may enact changes to regulations (like tax laws) or other laws that could affect profits.
  • Catastrophic Losses: Insurance companies are exposed to losses from big and unforeseen events that could reduce profitability, or make them less reliable and more of a risk.
  • Underwriting Risk: Poor underwriting can lead to losses and reduced profitability and can also erode trust in the brand.
  • Management Risk: The risk of poor decision-making or a failure to adapt to market changes always exists in any business.

Business Resilience

W. R. Berkley has shown significant resilience over the years, including during the 2008 financial crisis and COVID. Some reasons behind its strong resilience can be listed as:

  • Diverse Portfolio: As we mentioned earlier, the company operates in several markets with a variety of products, providing a certain level of balance and stability.
  • Prudent Underwriting: Their focus on specialty insurance allows for them to analyze risks and choose who to do business with effectively, limiting their overall exposure.
  • Financial Prudence: The company has historically employed a balanced approach toward debt management and maintaining a high investment-grade rating.

Even with the resilience, the company has certain challenges they are constantly facing. They require careful management in such times to ensure they can continue to earn a profit.

Understandability

The insurance industry is very difficult to understand and has many obscure terms that can be difficult to decipher for those who are not knowledgeable in the area. Combined with the fact that W. R. Berkley has a lot of business lines and a complex decentralized corporate structure, and the various factors that influence the profitability of their business, the company gets a rating of: 2 / 5. Even though the general idea is easy to understand, the financial reports and all the various factors that influence the business operations makes it relatively complex.

Balance Sheet Health

W. R. Berkley is generally well-capitalized and has adequate liquidity to weather a downturn, but in turn, that makes their returns on capital a bit smaller (as the money has to be safely invested in low yield, fixed-income instruments). Despite that, they have a solid financial position and seem able to manage the risks arising from debt quite well. The company gets a rating of 4 / 5 for the financial health rating.